Cardio

Cardio2010-09-17T14:02:39+00:00
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    Hi, I was wondering what a 90 minute Bikram class is equivalent to in terms of a cardio work out. Is it the same as a 30min jog or a 30min walk. They say your heart rate during cardio exercise should be over 120 for at least 20 minutes or something like that. So has anyone done a study or worn a heart rate monitor just to get an idea of how cardio it is ? I guess I’m asking as I find that my yoga class (2 times a week) has replaced my walking exercise…

    Thanks

    fraseram
    Participant
    Post count: 356

    it depends on the conditions of your studio and how hot they keep it my question would be how do you feel? does it feel like you are working?

    Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    yes but you can go to the gym and and lift weights for an hour and feel like you’re working but get very little cardio workout…so I was just wondering what is it’s equivalent. I think it’s important to know as a lot of people just do yoga and perhaps think that this is all the exercise they need when it may not be the case.

    Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    it would be great if someone with a heart rate monitor could wear it to class and report the results back to this thread. Things like average heart rate over an entire class, peak heart rate, time above a certain level..cheers 🙂

    (update; ok I’m going to buy one off ebay (waterproof :)) and take it into class a few times and report the results back on this thread if anyone is interested. I’ll try and distinguish between standing part and floor series etc)

    Gabrielle (The Hot Yoga Doctor)
    Forum Owner
    Post count: 3048

    Hi Gus

    Be my guest! You can be that someone! 😆

    Actually I KNOW that someone did do that and they has reported using it on this forum. Just can’t recall exactly when so I can’t put my finger on it. I popped the word ‘monitor’ in the search facility I found lots of posts with that word in it and didn’t scour them for that reference. Perhaps you can try there.

    I can tell you of course that thousands of people would agree that they feel that they are getting ample cardio exercise in the room!

    What happens for you?

    Namaste
    Gabrielle 🙂

    PS thanks for joining us at the forum!

    Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    yes my heart definately pounds. I find the floor series tends to make me sweat the most as you alternate between savasana and the floor poses…it will take a month or so to report back so keep an eye out.

    fraseram
    Participant
    Post count: 356

    ok ok here is the scoop ( I have one and have worn it )
    I practice at home in a converted sauna
    in the studio
    and in norm reg condtions
    what I found was pretty much what I expected based on what I felt like during and after each practice 😛
    PS calories burned is based on weight and VO2 max along with many other factors so I will give comparisons…… I am 4’6 and weigh 70 lbs I burn about 330 calories during a pretty intense hour long cardio session where my heart would be about 140-creeps up and finishing at 160 ish for the final 20 mins or so (so if you weighed 140 lbs you double calories burned to 660/hr)
    in my sauna I keep my conditions slightly more intense than in the studio and burn about 260 my heart rate goes up and down dramatically through out class but stays in ‘cardio zone’ for about a total 40 mins of the class
    in my studio I burn about 200 230
    in reg conditions its about like going for a walk
    so my summary is this …. if you FEEL like you’ve worked out and your heart is pumping …. IT IS 🙂 use your perceived rate of exertion to help guide you

    jtcb
    Participant
    Post count: 98

    The link below might give you an idea.

    I would say yes bikram yoga is a good cardio exercise. I can definitely feel my heart is pumping harder in the 90 minute class. Poses that involve stretching, pulling, and kicking will get the heart pumping in no time. I have heart attack in Standing Bow, Balancing Stick, Triangle, Full Locust, and Floor Bow.

    http://www.bikram-yoga-noosa-australia.com/weight-loss-and-yoga.htm

    Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    ok thanks guys that is starting to answer my questions. The calculator is great. I’m satisfied that a 90min Bikram class more than substitutes for say a 45 minute walk however there are perhaps some things we cant measure so I will try and keep walking as well 🙂 I’ve ordered my pulse watch from Ebay so will report on what happens during the class…cheers

    Pamela0414
    Participant
    Post count: 58

    I also think it depends on weight and fitness level. I am positive I am getting a very good cardio workout in my class. Only because I am not very fit cardiovasularly. There are times I know my heart rate is too high and I have to take a Savasana break. I am sure someone in good cardiovascular shape needs to do a lot more work to get their heart rate up. Either way, Bikram is a cardio exercise for how long and equivilent? I think it depends on the person.

    Anonymous
    Guest
    Post count: 98

    Hi there!

    I guess the question is this: how much exercise do you believe you need and for what purpose? Are you exercising for muscle strength, for functional ability, for cardiovascular improvement, for balance, for core strength, for calories burned? The question that I can’t decipher from your post and what you imply but don’t state is one of how much of what exercise for what purpose do you believe you need to accomplish your goal (which isn’t stated).

    Bikram’s Yoga is a multi-purpose exercise. It exercises all of your muscles and systems within the 90 minutes. You WILL have improved cardiovascular functioning, improved muscle strength and improved core strength and balance if you do Bikram’s Yoga regularly and frequently enough to make a difference, which is 3 or 4 times a week (just as you need to run 3 or 4 times a week to improve your cardiovascular system, for example).

    So, I think your question is pretty much unanswerable in the sense that you haven’t defined what your personal fitness goals are and what your personal belief system is with respect to “required exercise amounts”. If you are looking to run a marathon, Bikram’s Yoga will get you to a reasonable start level of overall fitness for you to begin marathon training. If you are looking for gym muscles, you’ll need to lift. If you are looking for functional muscular improvement, Bikram’s Yoga will definitely help. If you are looking for improved balance, Bikram’s Yoga will definitely help. But what does it equate to? That depends on the class, how hard you work, how hot the studio is, and your starting fitness level. And for alot of people, 3 or 4 Bikram’s Yoga classes a week is more than enough overall exercise to maintain and improve balance, muscular strength, endurance, cardiovascular ability, and bone mass.

    JMHO!

    Freia

    Gus1
    Participant
    Post count: 20

    ok update, I’ve been going for about 5 weeks now. Everything going good. My heart rate is pounding so I know when I get the pulse watch it will show that bikram is a strong cardio workout (heart) and as the calculator suggests it burns MAJOR calories. I have lost a lot of weight in the time. I’m also considering going to 1/2 raw 1/2 cooked after reading books by Tonya Zavasta. She is also a big Bikram fan.

    There is just one thing though that I’ve noticed and what I suspected about yoga compared to other forms of exercise like riding a bike, walking and running etc. I find that my breathing is not labored, i.e it is slow and steady EVEN though my heart is going probably going 180 beats per minute. This is definately a good thing I think but it leaves me wondering if you should do other forms of exercise like walking where you actually get a bit of puff up ?

    These are strange things…like in Bikram your heart is pounding but you are not using a lot of oxygen in your calorie burn (which is great and unusual at the same time !), whereas running you use ALOT of oxygen and burn similar if not less calories. For you guys that only do bikram try going for a walk / run up a single hill and see what I mean. You will be puffing !

    What does this mean ? I’m not sure but I think puffing is good also but not alot as too much oxygen can be bad (it is believed that the faster your breath the shorter your life).

    Anyway just some thoughts. Namaste 🙂

    wladmin99
    Participant
    Post count: 14

    This is an older post/thread…… So i am not sure whether i will get an answer.

    I play recreational Ice Hockey, in an Oldtimer league (35yrs+). As you may know, in hockey you go in short bursts, with rest periods on the bench. Having strong legs, and being able to do close to full exertion skating for about 45 seconds followed by rest/recovery and back over the boards…..

    In hockey, some guys can skate effortlessly, and others are always laboring… Exhausted by the end of their shifts…. I fall into the latter category.

    I too am wondering about the cardio benefit of Hot Yoga. Certainly the stretching, back mobility, and toning is helping my game.

    I don’t know alot about fitness or exercise science, but from reading these posts, Cardio seems to be measured by heart rate….

    I am wondering whether the “cardio” in hot yoga (ie.the increased heart rate) is sufficient training to get me to improve my endurance in hockey – such that i can either skate for longer shifts, go all out during my shifts, and not be so exhausted by the end of my shifts?

    Intuitively, i would think i would have to either do interval running or skating, or spinning … Maybe Tabata style (HIIT High Intensity Interval Training) to get better…..

    I also think that simply going jogging or running, the way i see most people doing it: shuffling along in the most efficient / least movement, would not be of much benefit for hockey….

    Woild love to jear from soemone who has simlar demands….

    Gabrielle (The Hot Yoga Doctor)
    Forum Owner
    Post count: 3048

    Hi Wayne

    Thanks for posting – even if it’s an old thread revived. 😛 You’re welcome to do that anytime.

    OK, so here’s my input for you: Bikram or hot yoga is ideal interval training. It will help you with your hockey and other stamina!

    There are PLENTY of anecdotes to support that. For example, Robert and I used to spend a lot of time on motorcycle race tracks. Stamina and fitness were hugely effected. The fine distinctions of balance static and in motion are improved. Plus you get a boost in your recoverability and even your risk of damage is lessened because of increased agility.

    In short: It’s all good!

    Namaste
    Gabrielle 🙂

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Go to Top