Using a towel for stability

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

Author

Posts
MsMel
Participant

November 20, 2009 at 5:31 am

Post count: 1

#1616

I have knee problems and although I enjoy Bikram yoga, I do find it can be hard on my knees if I don’t take the proper precautions.

One of those precautions is to turn my towel perpendicular when I do Triangle pose, as the floor of my yoga studio is a rubbery material that gets very slippery under sweaty feet. Unfortunately, one instructor at my studio has taken to singling me out in front of class to accuse me of “cheating” because of this. (Let’s not even get into how badly she ruins my zen-like state by doing this!) I have already explained to her that I have tried doing Triangle without the towel, and the pressure on my knee is too painful without the towel providing a little extra stability. Either I do this modified version, or I do not do it at all.

I am pretty sure it is not an alignment issue- it is just how my knee feels in certain positions (in any activity).

At the end of the day, who cares if I take a “shortcut” or “cheat” (although I don’t consider it that) to ensure the posture is not painful or potentially harmful? I am still deriving some benefit, and avoiding knee pain that persists after the posture is done. My basic question, then– is this concept of using the towel so abhorrent to other practitioners? What happened to listening to your body? It is my practice, after all…

Gabrielle (The Hot Yoga Doctor)
Forum Owner

November 20, 2009 at 8:33 am

Post count: 3048

#5864

Hi Melissa

It is funny how people get a little persnickety about certain details. We all do! It sometimes is even worth it. Other times it is wasted energy.

I want to give you a different spin on it. If you were at a regular class of yoga you would turn your body to the side and step out along the length of your mat whenever you did a warrior pose. In fact you would step out so that at all times your base would be your mat.

If you have a knee problem or a hip problem then a slippery floor could be so dangerous. It seems you are aware of the danger.

It could be fixed by a technique modification. I would have to drill down a little more to work out the best out of the few approaches I could offer you.

By the way I don’t consider you to be cheating. When you do step out along your mat instead of across it, you are actually invited to explore your relationship with the mat. Here’s something else, at my home studio we actually perform the whole standing series with the towel across the mat. We have carpet and we find that the room will positively stink if we sweat on the floor, but with the towel cross ways the carpet stays fresh and clean and we take our sweat away from the room and we wash it away soon after. I am not against using a towel the other way. I am against towel adjusting for particular poses, or fixing or smoothing out a towel because it bunches up.

Your teacher’s admonishments are not appropriate especially since you slip on the rubbery floor. I could ask you whether others have a problem slipping as well. Your state being ruined is your own responsibility however and as hard as it is to totally ignore that, you really have to. You are not being disrespectful, I should think it is the other way around. In my opinion if she can’t offer you the tools to fix that (technical points, modifications to your own technique or even using a prop) then she should leave you alone.

It could be that she is noticing you changing your towel just before triangle. Why don’t you start and then keep your towel that way from the beginning of class and only change it when you get to the floor? There are no rules about having to do it a certain way.

Please go and look at all the other tips on triangle because there are some valuable tips on how not to slip. One of those is here: Slipping and Sliding Feet and another is here: What Should I Try To Be Accomplishing In This Pose. It is possible that I can give you another tip but I want you to see if these (and those in the other threads) work first.

It is possible that for the moment you could benefit from not lunging so far down (see second link for details) by not stepping out as far which means thigh not quite parallel to ground. Keep the shin vertical. If this still doesn’t give you a feeling of safety then get back to me. I have other great tips to share.

Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂

monkeypicked
Participant

November 20, 2009 at 5:52 pm

Post count: 18

#5865

I don’t like the term “cheating”. When you use a crutch you don’t learn to walk without it. I know that triangle is hard, we all struggle with it but you have to work hard and get past the point o relying on a tool to help you. You have the power to fix this on your own. You are your own tool. Rajashree spoke about this the other day. She said that when you use the towel you aren’t using all of your muscles and developing them in the same way.
I know it’s frustrating to be called out in front of class, but instead of thinking about it as being reprimanded think about it as the teacher cares enough to help you. What if you asked your teacher to double check your alignment after class? Maybe you come out of it early for a while. But you will get stronger. Then you will do triangle perfectly. It just takes time. There are no short cuts.
Author

Posts