The Hot Yoga Doctor – Free Bikram and Hot Yoga Resources › Hot Yoga Doctor Forum › General Hot Yoga Discussion › Weight Loss and Hot Yoga › weight gain, water retention, bloating…
The Hot Yoga Doctor – Free Bikram and Hot Yoga Resources › Hot Yoga Doctor Forum › General Hot Yoga Discussion › Weight Loss and Hot Yoga › weight gain, water retention, bloating…
-
AuthorPosts
-
I’m feeling icky. I have been doing hot yoga 4-5 times a week for about 6 weeks now. At first I loved it!! I used to run and lift weights at the gym and was getting really bored with my workout and uninspired. Hot yoga was wonderful, especially for an old, ex-gymnast/dancer like me! I was feeling great, motivated and inspired and stopped going to the gym. I could happily do this every day.
However, I am now feeling disappointed and deflated. I have gained a few pounds and, although I know the scale should not be of great importance, I cannot fit into most of my jeans! Also, I feel bloated, like I’m retaining water and have had to remove (with some difficulty) the rings I’ve worn regularly for years and years! I don’t care what my weight is (I’m generally in a very normal range), I just don’t want to feel like this.
I sweat a lot, but drink lots of water throughout the day and feel no other symptoms that I may be dehydrated. I eat well and haven’t changed my diet. I keep drinking more and more water, but my fingers especially are still puffy and I’m uncomfortable. I don’t know how much more I can drink. What’s going on?!
I really don’t want to give up on hot yoga, nor do I want to go back to my old gym routine. I don’t have the time to do both and it would be very expensive to keep both memberships. What should I try before I give up on this?
rest easy lol this is a normal sign of heat acclimatization so it should go away in a week or so. if not get your electrolytes checked as it can also mean an imbalance
Hi Mary
I disagree with Amy (sorry Amy 😉 ) I don’t think it is a sign of heat acclimatization. I hope you don’t mind but we our out the door on this glorious Sunday morning and I will be back to troubleshoot this with you later today or your tomorrow!
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂Conservation of sodium chloride (NaCl) also occurs during heat acclimatization. The NaCl losses in sweat and urine decrease during days 3-9 of heat acclimatization, resulting in an expanded extracellular fluid volume. Subsequently, NaCl losses in sweat and urine increase toward pre-acclimatization levels, once physiologic strain (i.e., cardiovascular, thermal) moderates. Francesconi and colleagues (1993) recently demonstrated that NaCl losses, during a strenuous 10-day heat acclimatization protocol, were related to plasma renin (PR) and plasma aldosterone (A) concentrations. When subjects consumed a low salt diet (4g NaCl per day) and a moderate salt diet (8g NaCl per day), both PR and A increased during the first four days of heat acclimatization, but decreased during the remaining 6 days of heat acclimatization. The improved cardiovascular stability, which occurred on days 1-4 of heat acclimatization, allowed equivalent exercise performance with both diets and apparently reduced the stimulation and need for large elevations of PR and A. No change in plasma levels of arginine vasopressin (AVP) were observed across time, in either dietary group, possibly because hourly water intake matched the fluid lost in sweat. Usually, AVP synthesis is stimulated by an increase in plasma osmolarity or alterations in blood pressure, plasma volume, and renal or hepatic blood blow. Therefore, it is unlikely that the ability to successfully sustain exercise, during the latter days of the heat acclimatization process, is specifically related to the action of hormones that regulate fluid-electrolyte balance. This is particularly true when salt balance has been achieved
this swelling and retention happens to me when I come back from a break or have a few hot classes in a row. it goes away in a few days to a week
The strange thing is that I was feeling so great for the first 3-4 weeks, it’s only been the last 2 that I’ve felt so awful. A number of times, I’ve had to get up in the middle of the night to remove my rings – I could feel them getter tighter and tighter. This last time, 2 days ago, I needed soap and baby oil to get them off! These are rings I’ve worn for 10 years (or more) and I haven’t put them on again.
My energy is so low – at yesterday’s class, I actually sat out a few poses which I’ve never done before and today I didn’t go at all. I’ve been drinking electrolyte drinks today to see if that relieves any of this. If this should “normalize” in a week or so… why would I be feeling like this now, after feeling great for the first few weeks? I would have thought I’d have an adjustment period at first, but would have acclimated after the first few weeks.
what is happening is that your body is losing salt and minerals through sweating so in defense it hangs onto to all the sodium in your blood it can. It is happening now rather than before because it takes a bit for your levels to get out of whack….. the drinks should help and if it does not get better soon get your levels checked
ps the low energy is also a good indicator of low blood sodium
pps what I meant by normalizing after a week is a week or so after the bloat starts…..this is all research I’ve done carefully and discussed with doctor after being in hosp over night for low blood sodium levels …. not that your case is like mine, what happened to me is an extreme circumstance. Just that it is normal for your body to hang on to salt when it is loosing it all of a sudden and that once it gets used to it it should relax and let go if it does not … look into it to make sure you are replacing your minerals well enough
Hi Amy
I do know where you’re coming from. And heat acclimatization happens within the first 2 weeks. I sense there is more going on here because this person is a regular yogini and has been going for 6 weeks. Your quote from the study/book is about people in day 3-9. Would you like to paraphrase that excerpt with your own words to explain what you think is happening? Because I don’t see that your quote means that Mary’s system is bloated with fluid or accurately describes the situation.
If Mary were only going once a week and not giving her system enough heat exposure to acclimatize then in my opinion she may not acclimatize in the regular way. However I think it could be something else.
Mary, you mention you are drinking a lot. What color is your urine throughout the day. What electrolytes are you taking? Do you take sea salt or regular table salt with your food? What does ‘good diet’ mean to you? What are you eating? What else is going on in your life? Just shooting some questions here to stimulate a discussion.
Just now Amy has posted her comments about the salt. Which is kinda where I am heading but I don’t think it’s either ‘perfectly normal’ or to do with acclimatization.
I would be concerned. I would like to chat with you about some finer points before recommending anything.
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂what I meant to say…. and perhaps did not put it very well was this…
Bloating and hanging on to fluid IS a a sign of acclimatization AND it is also a sign of your electrolytes being off. I would too be concerned and am concerned which is why i suggested she get her levels checked. If it is a normal sign of your body adjusting to heat it should go away after a couple of days to a week after it started if it continues then your levels may be off.
especially if you are drinking A LOT of water (with no hymilain or other sea salts/electrolyte replacements) your blood sodium may be low. In my experience (and that is the only place I am speaking from and not pretending to be an expert 😉 ) that is what happened to me…. I was overly preoccupied with getting dehydrated and drank too much water LOL and diluted my blood. There are lots of things though that can cause an imbalanceWhen I was starting to do hot yoga, it took me a long time to acclimatize to the heat (2-3 weeks). I tried to drink a lot of water to feel better. But…..I am living in a place where tap water is not suitable for drinking and I was always taking water that we bought in big 20 liter bottles. This water is obtained from reversed osmosis! Drinking water that is obtained from reversed osmosis contains no salt at all and is like distilled water. When I changed to bottled mineral water, I improved a lot. I also tend to have a low blood pressure and changing over to sea salt also helped.
This has maybe not a lot to do with the original question -I never had swollen limbs- but I just want to share my experience that I felt worse in the beginning when I was drinking more water! Make sure your water always contains some salts/minerals or mix a little bit of salt into your water (but be careful with that if you tend to have a high blood pressure and look for salt that is high in potassium and not in sodium).
For the rest I try use the advice of Gabrielle given elsewhere on this forum: check the colour of your urine, it should never be very yellow, but very light in colour.Okay, I’m trying to make sense of all this… I don’t quite understand – is there a difference between having low electrolytes and/or low sodium or are they one and the same? I’ve been drinking electrolyte drinks all day yesterday, but still cannot put on a ring today. I am going to try yoga today.
Some more info: I am 5′ 4″ (162 cm) and weigh about 130-135. I’m a stay-at-home mom to 2 kids ages 4 and 6. My in-laws are visiting from Oz, we are having a wonderful time and my life is pretty relaxed right now. My general diet is “good” in that I eat lots of fresh fruit and veg from our garden, not too many carbs, try to stay away from processed foods. I am not vegetarian, but we consume lean meats and fish and do not have meat daily. We do eat dairy, so some cheese, milk and eggs. Brown rice, salads – our garden is producing lots of tomatoes and zucchini right now, so lots of those! I cook with sea salt, but have normal table salt of the table. I do not add salt to everything, but have never really limited what I use because I’ve never had an issue. I’ve always been pretty healthy and athletic and tend to have low-to-normal blood pressure (110/70). I have not changed my eating habits in the past few months. My urine is not dark and I don’t feel dehydrated.
Does that give you any further ideas? If I have low sodium, how is that remedied? Thanks!
salt is one of the electrolytes but there are many minerals our body loses in sweat. are you peeing all the time?? or at least more than normal? if you have low blood sodium you will pee all the time and have very light urine
I’m not peeing more than normal. I went to yoga today and had a good practice. I didn’t feel such low energy today – the session is never “easy” but I wasn’t struggling either – a perfectly normal practice. I made sure to drink before, during and after and have had 750 ml electrolyte water as well. I feel fine, but my hands are still very puffy and feel no change with any of the bloating.
to diagnose …… and get guidance or treatment of any condition should be done by a doc. i’m only sharing my experience and research. your situation may be something totally different.
to treat a low blood sodium i needed less water and more salt and other minerals …… so when replacing fluids i had to take tablets as recommended by my doc.
the long and short is even if you are taking special drinks…. if you are drinking too much reg water on top you will still dilute your blood ( I was taking a drink too )Hi Mary
There is a condition of drinking too much water and depleting sodium. It’s called hyponatremia. It’s very serious and people die from that.
Please search online for hyponatremia. Also search for mild hyponatremia because the first search will give you the really serious symptoms which from your posts you have not indicated. However you could possibly have mild symptoms.
It’s really worth checking out. It is possible that the excessive sweating through many classes along with the amount of water you are drinking is causing some fluid retention. It’s counter-intuitive isn’t it?
You really should see a doctor.
You mention you drink a lot. How much water do you drink?
We could go down the track of what you’re eating and see if there’s something in your diet that is present or lacking. You could tell me if you cook most of your food. And you should get rid of your table salt and only use the sea salt for everything gastronomic for you and your family, from now on. That other stuff is sea salt with EVERY SINGLE BIT of goodness extracted so that all that’s left is sodium chloride. Sea salt is a necessary addition to your diet that will help keep your body in balance. (I have a friend who just recently told me that because salt is so bad for you, that she and her family have none. She had signs of some very poor electrolyte balance and I went out and bought her Himalayan salt that day).
To answer a previous question above; you asked about electrolytes. Sodium or Na+ is just one electrolyte present in the body. There are a number of them. They regulate MANY complex systems. If you are low in electrolytes (I won’t get specific here) then your nerves may not fire correctly, your muscles may not function optimally (spasms, twitching, weakness) your heart may not function well, your blood will not have the right balance (acid-base), your oxygen delivery will be affected and so on and so forth. Your mood may be affected. Electrolytes control blood pressure and help regulate the amount of fluid in the body. Yes, if you are depleted then you could get some water retention as Amy said in an effort to preserve your electrolyte levels.
You may have read elsewhere the suggestion to salt your food with sea salt or even salt your water. If indeed you are depleted then you need a teaspoon every day. Go get some quality sea salt (perhaps from a health food store: Celtic, Himalayan, Hawaiian).
You could take a break from the yoga for a week (I know, you don’t want to 😉 ) or even just 3-4 days to see if the lack of yoga actually does make the puffiness subside. The aim would be to see if the same habits minus the yoga affects you differently. Then go back and see what happens.
[strong]YOUR MISSION NOW: Get a blood test [/strong](include your Vitamin D levels by asking for a 25 hydroxy test). The other part of your mission methinks: Take a few days off hot yoga!
Please keep us posted. Please get tested.
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂Thank you for your advice and caring. I’ve been out of town and then without a computer, so I haven’t been able to reply. I had already read some about hyponatremia and was fairly certain I could rule that out, so no worries there. I went to my doctor and got complete blood work done – kidney function, thyroid, blood sugar etc. and nothing came back abnormal. During this time, instead of drinking just water, I really upped my electrolyte intake with Smartwater and other electrolyte drinks, both during class and throughout the day, and that really made the difference. I took 10 days off due to travel, but have now been back for 2 weeks, going about 4 times a week and I feel back to normal. Actually, I feel great.
It’s still puzzling to me. I live in AZ so it’s been over 100 degrees and maybe that compounded with the hot yoga threw my body out of whack. I began this yoga practice in May, just as the temp was rapidly rising into summer. I’ve lived in this heat for years and never felt the necessity to hydrate with more than plain water, even when I was running 5K 4 times a week. Anyway, whatever the cause, I’m feeling good and keeping up my electrolytes! Thanks again.
Hmmm… it also just occurred to me that the water I’d been taking to yoga was usually from our reverse-osmosis system. Our tap water is very high in chlorine, among other stuff, so we have an RO system on the kitchen sink, but not connected to the fridge. I usually use both sources of water, but had been filling our metal bottles we take to yoga with only the nice RO water, which tastes much better. Maybe that’s been a factor as well.
Hi Mary
I think you’ve hit on something quite significant. Reverse osmosis water is like distilled water to a great extent. Not much in there. Great taste but the minerals and ions disappear too!
It must be satisfying to know that the changes you’ve made are already demonstrating a positive difference for you
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂I am fairly new to hot yoga…. I’ve been doing HY for about 5 weeks now… Unfortunately my practice has been sporadic, once a week here, twice a week there… but last week I went 4 times…
I am now feeling much like the person in the original post on this thread. BLOATED and gross. My jeans feel tighter and I feel icky and swollen.
I try to drink at least a liter and a half before class during the day… I drink almost a liter during… and also about 1 after. Sometimes I can only drink like a half liter before class.
I am now concerned that my sodium is out of whack or my body is trying to get used to the extreme heat. I see some recomendations about increasing electrolytes… but how? Would Pedialyte work? Gatorade? Are there vitamins that contain sodium?
Hi Kira
Yep, you had better do something! Actually all the information is in this thread. Please go and read the recommendations in detail. Go and buy yourself some proper sea salt and start to use that in your food and even pop some in your water.
You should consider taking a teaspoon every day. Go and buy electrolytes if you like but you may find the salt works for you.
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂I actually found this site via this thread after doing a google search for “temporary weight gain after yoga” I just had my first class last night and I am very militant with diet. However this am I was up two lbs on the scale. I read through this thread with a little relief seeing this could happen, and I have added sea salt to today’s shopping list.
Hi Heather
That’s great. A 2 pound increase overnight is something to pay attention to. Hey, just wondering do you weigh yourself everyday or is it that you did so this time because you felt different?
Namaste
Gabrielle 🙂I way myself every morning at the same time before I eat or drink. I am militant about it. I have lost 100 lbs and have maintained that for 6 yrs, so daily weigh in is what works for me.
Hi. I have had the same issue, a 2 pound weight gain after two sessions. I too have maintained my weight for months even through the holidays and I haven’t changed any of my eating habits. I’d like to incorporate hot yoga into my regular routine – striving for 3 days per week. I am hopeful the sea salt and smart water will help, as my stomach is very puffy and I’m extremely uncomfortable.
I have been having the same problem, I have been doing hot yoga for three months and just finished a 30 day challenge. I have been eating better and trying to lose weight but nothing has changed. When I did hot yoga a few years ago I had the same issue, and finally changed back to going to a gym, and within a few weeks the weight came off like magic. Could hot yoga be causing water weight? I would like to continue my practice, but not if it is causing me to retain unnecessary weight.
I don’t weigh myself very often but I did about 2-3 weeks ago and I was the same weight I’ve been all year. It is where I hang out +/- a couple of pounds.
Well lately I’ve been feeling that menstrual bloat -I usually get it for a day or two but this time it has been about a week. My belly just feels huge and distended -I’m always amazed that I can feel like that one day and then ready for the skinny jeans the next. It doesn’t feel like regular “weight-gain” – which I can usually see on my face and in my thighs. And my thighs are leaner and smaller than ever.
So I jumped on the scale this morning and I’ve put on 7lbs!! In like 2 weeks!! Without any major changes to my diet. I don’t eat a great diet because of food anxiety issues but I’ve worked out what works for me and I haven’t changed it much. The changes over the last few weeks:
1) upped my hot yoga to 5x a week -I had done 75 classes at about 3-4 classes a week and then took 3 weeks off due to vacation and illness and when I started back I started back with 5x a week.
2) Cut out my box-a-day wheat thins habit – replaced with pretzels -less of them
3) Started drinking coconut water for electrolytesI’ve been craving salt like crazy -as I do with hot yoga. I’m sweating more than normal it seems in my yoga classes. I can’t do sea salt because I have a shellfish allergy and since sea salt is all the rage they have been harvesting it in a way that gets shellfish in it.
ETA -I know some of it is likely muscle gain -but I’m more concerned about the belly bloat feeling than the details of the number.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.