The Hot Yoga Doctor – Free Bikram and Hot Yoga Resources › Hot Yoga Doctor Forum › Busting Some Big-A$$ Hot Yoga Myths
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
in reply to: No roon for sexism in yoga….. #5541
I agree with Springtime. It’s hard enough to breathe during rabbit pose as it is.
in reply to: Ladies, Please your advice #5277I like Shakti. Activa has some nice things, but I am not sure that they are green.
Hi Jeanette,
As Gabrielle referenced above, I have also been having some long term issues with my hamstrings. I’ve lost track of how long, but it has been over two years now. I initially injured them while doing vinyasa yoga, or should I say overdoing? It also probably didn’t help when a guy friend and I were competing – showing off – our yoga flexibility at a party. :red: During all of this time, I have been trying to heal the injury through yoga. I have kept that up because I thought that I could fix it myself and I assumed that, if I went to my doctor he would just say to quit yoga and take ibuprofen. I finally went to a sports medicine physical therapist and have made great progress over the last few months, but am still not at 100%. Here’s what I have learned:1- All of the pain that I had was right at the top of my hamstrings where they connect at the butt. Per PT, the injury was actually in the belly of the hamstrings and the scar tissue had limited my flexibility so much that I was hurting the connecting tendons by yanking on them while stretching.
2- Even though I thought that my legs were super strong, I found out that my hamstrings have grown super weak. He proved it to me by having me push against his hand while using my hamstring strength and my leg just started shaking like crazy.
3- Basically, over the last two years since I did not heal the injury and have continued to push through it, I have built up a significant amount of scar tissue which has caused a significant decrease in strength and flexibility of the hamstring. It’s a vicious cycle.
4- Interesting note, the doc thinks that I aggravated the problem in yoga–not just by continuing to stretch into pain–but also by compensating for the injury by using the other muscles in my legs and butt. I DO have very strong quads. One of the things that may have made it worse was that the hamstring is key while balancing on one leg. By doing that balancing while the hamstring was weak, it may have made it worse. Note that my balance has been pretty bad comparatively speaking. I could never figure out why. Guess what–it’s getting a lot better now.
5- All that said, the doc never said that I should quit going to yoga. I just need to strengthen the hammies and avoid overstretching.Here’s how am I fixing it:
1- Physical therapy including electrical stimulation, sonograms and some pretty harsh massage using metal implements to break down the scar tissue. Have gotten a few bruises, but it seems to be working.
2- Gradually increasing difficulty hamstring exercises to rebuild the strength. Per doc, I need to work on the eccentric (Gabrielle is that right?) strength. An example is using a hamstring weight machine and using both legs to lift a fairly heavy weight and then using only one leg to slowly lower it back down.
3- Yoga. I am maintaining the flexibility and further working on the strength in yoga class.I am really excited because this week I just went to my first pain free yoga class in over two years. Not only did it not hurt during class, but it didn’t hurt the next day either! 🙂
Lessons learned: Don’t ignore your hamstring pain. It probably won’t just go away on its own. The right doctor/physio/chiropractor/whatever will probably be able to help you heal.
Best of Luck!
Cindyin reply to: So what do you wear? #5177Good for you. I really think that people are only worried about their own body and not really concerned with everyone else. I just figure that if someone is concerned about my cellulite, it’s their problem, not mine.
in reply to: YogaBody supplement really works #5168I was quite skeptical as to whether a supplement could help flexibility, recovery time, etc. I decided to try it as I am working through a long-time hamstring issue and felt that it couldn’t hurt. All I can say is that I have had some very enjoyable classes since I started taking YogaBody. It is kind of hard to describe. It is like it is more peaceful moving into the poses. I am able to go just a little bit deeper than usual. Also, I am not going to class as frequently as usual (about 3 days per wk now) to give my hamstrings a rest. Usually I get sore muscles when I go this infrequently and I haven’t since I started the YogaBody.
I have not started the stretching regimen as I am trying to be very careful of my hamstrings at this point. I may just do four days and skip the hamstring stretches for now.
One thing that I am noticing… I am also taking Menersa (an herbal supplement for perimenopausal symptoms) and Body Balance. All three of these supplements suggest that they might boost energy. Some days I am feeling a little jittery. I need to figure out how to balance all of these and still get the benefits.
I recommend that you try it!
in reply to: So what do you wear? #5154I can’t imagine wearing underwear under my yoga shorts. I don’t want the distraction of panties riding up. Really, what is the difference? The yoga shorts have built in cotton panels and I sweat so much anyway that I will be throwing them in the washing machine as soon as I get home.
About one month into my Bikram experience, I decided that the torture chamber was no place for modesty. Don’t get me wrong, all private parts are well covered, but I bare my tummy in spite of potentially embarrassing mid-section rolls and–while I don’t wear short shorts–sometimes people could see some cellulite on my thighs if they cared to look. The point is that I am comfortable and don’t have to pull and readjust my clothing while trying to concentrate on the task at hand.
in reply to: First part of locust: how and why… #5153I also feel like I have more success if I push my body forward and reach toward my feet with my hands. I will never get my shoulders on the floor due to my bust. This technique has worked well for me, though.
in reply to: Better ability to use nutrients from food? #5145Congratulations! It sounds to me like you have gained some muscle weight from your yoga. If your dress size has changed already, then you are definitely on the right track!
When I started Bikram a year ago, I felt like I needed to lose 10 pounds to get back to my regular weight and so that my clothes would fit me again. I remember that I sent a distressed post to Gabrielle wondering how I could possibly not be losing weight after a few months of this intense yoga. I felt like I was working SO hard and not seeing any impact on the scale. Guess what happened–I did not lose ANY weight according to the scale. However, all of my clothes now fit again. Basically, I am 10 pounds heavier than I look. Hmmm, I have all of the many benefits of yoga–including looking thinner–but the scale tells me otherwise. I gave my scale away.
Maybe it would make sense for your goal to be based on measurements or body fat percentage instead of pounds? That might make you feel better about your journey.
I think that more frequent and smaller meals is a great idea. I also think that 1000 calories is a really small amount of calories to get by on when you are exerting yourself so much in yoga. Everyone is different, though. You asked if yogis survive on very little food. I can only speak for myself on that, but I actually eat about as much as my 6’4″ boyfriend does. As long as I go to yoga 4-6 times per week and walk about 3 miles 4-5 days per week, I do not have any concern with weight gain. I do try to eat healthy food. I don’t eat processed food, cook with olive oil, lots of veggies (I seem to have trouble getting the fruit in), very little white flour or sweets. I also include nuts, avocados and dark chocolate in my diet. I believe that the concept of including enough MUFAs (look it up online) is a good one.
Best of Luck and, again, congratulations on your success thus far.
Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: Bikram for weight loss – any stories for me?! #5110I think that we only gain weight, lose muscle, lose flexibility as we get older because we allow that to happen. I have read many articles that say that we do not have to lose any muscle or flexibility as we grow older. I fully intend to do Bikram yoga for another 40 years and I’m now 46 years old. (note that it will likely take 40 years to reach my full expression of the poses.) 🙂
I go to Bikram about 4 times per week on average and would prefer to go 6. I also walk 5 times per week about 45 minutes per time. Like I said above, I am 46 years old. At this level of exercise I am able to eat pretty much anything that I want without gaining weight. I am not super thin, but am a healthy size. I am 5’8″ tall and wear a size 10. At this level of exercise, I know that I could be thinner if I cut back on my calorie intake, but it’s just not that important to me. I think that it is most important to be healthy and enjoy life’s experiences to the fullest extent possible. One of those experiences that I enjoy is good food and wine. :red:
Note that this attitude is fairly new to me. I used to teach aerobics classes, run, walk, weight train, anything to try to be thinner. Age and Bikram have helped me to get past that obsession and I’ve never been happier!
Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: Bikram & Weight Loss & other benefits! #5108Salrj,
I have been doing Bikram yoga for about a year now. I expected to lose some weight as I was doing it because it is so physically challenging. Over time I have gotten thinner, but have not lost one pound. It is really interesting that I now wear clothes that used to fit me when I was 10 pounds lighter! I have gone down one-two dress sizes. This tells me that I have gained a significant amount of muscle–which is heavier–and lost a good bit of body fat. What is really interesting is that I have always worked out very regularly before I started Bikram without having this impact.At first, I was watching the scales and was very discouraged that I had not lost any weight. Over time I realized that I could wear smaller size clothing and that my weight no longer fluctuates. It is amazing how my weight is the same every time that I step on the scale now.
Something that is even more interesting is that I no longer feel compelled to go to my Bikram classes as a measure to control my weight. I go because of the way that it makes me feel. I feel stronger physically, mentally and emotionally. Now I go for my health.
Enjoy your journey!
Cindyin reply to: Yoga Etiquette Question #5066So was that how you met or was it after you were married? I think that it is wonderful that the two of you work together like you do.
I was thinking about this post yesterday during an all day seminar given by Rajashree. The room was much more crowded than I was used to. When we went into Full Locust, I ended up not only bumping hands with the people on either side, but we pretty much bumped arms and hands through the whole pose. Everyone seemed ok with it, though. I would have thought that would bother me, but it really didn’t. It kind of added a sense of friendliness–like we’re in this together.
in reply to: Rajashree Seminar #5065The seminar was absolutely wonderful! 🙂 Rajashree is very charming, soft-spoken, but firm about doing the yoga the right way. There was so much energy in the room with so many enthusiastic people there for the class and pose clinic.
I did talk with Rajashree briefly about my hamstrings, but didn’t want to take a lot of time as there were so many people who wanted to speak with her.
I highly recommend this seminar if anyone has the opportunity to attend one.
Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: Yoga Etiquette Question #5044Our yoga room is not generally that crowded, but there have been times when it is. One time the lady next to me and I bumped hands when moving into Locust. Instead of startling away, she gave my hand a nice friendly squeeze and smiled at me. That made me feel really good. I suppose that there is some risk of offending using that approach as some people do not want there hand to be squeezed and don’t want to be distracted from the yoga.
in reply to: Triangle Pose with long legs #4992I am glad to hear that this technique helped. I learned to use breathing and counting my breath as a means of maintaining control and focus 27 years ago when my first son was born. When my second son was born a few years later, I rejected the Lamaze breathing method and found a book with breathing techniques that are quite similar to some pranayama techniques that I am just now encountering officially. Over the years, I have found this to be a very powerful tool when dealing with physical pain, emotional distress or other types of discomfort.
The comments that I receive the most frequently from instructors or other students is that I have a very calm and focused practice. I mostly attribute this to the focused breathing.
That’s great that you are progressing so fast. Enjoy the advanced class, I hear that they are quite challenging.
in reply to: New since last view… #4991Robert,
I see the om sign on the VIP Forum, but not in the general one. There are a lot more posts in the general forum so I think that it would be useful to have the same feature here.
Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: Hand flat no the floor? #4966Hi Gabrielle,
I mean where my fingers attach to the palm. Let’s say that I have my left hand behind me on the floor. If the palm is flat, then I can twist back far enough to look straight behind me. If I then push up slightly onto the ball of my hand I can externally rotate my left shoulder and open up and twist a good bit further. In fact, I can see my profile in the mirror at that point.I just wanted to be sure that this is ok.
thanks,
Cindyin reply to: Triangle Pose with long legs #4959Hi Gummisteph,
I am also 5’8″ and have long legs. I was having trouble with my feet sliding apart in the beginning, but I have followed all of Gabrielle’s advice and the issue has corrected itself over time. I do find that this is a pose in which I have to play mind games with myself sometimes. I usually do the following:1- when I step to the side of my mat before moving into the pose, I meet my eyes in the mirror, take a deep breath and take that instant to completely and consciously relax every part of my body. I take two breaths if the instructor allows that much time, but that is rare.
2- I have a few instructors who have us hold the initial lunge for a few beats before tilting into the pose. (sometimes I think that I don’t like them–just kidding). When we move into the pose, I tell myself what a relief it is. I do think that the intial lunge when you are upright is harder than the pose itself.
3- Once in the pose I do a mental inventory from front to back– heel pressed down, knee not past toes, elbow at knee, elbow pushing knee back, not slumping forward but lifting towards ceiling, hip down, spinal twist going, extended leg straight and foot flat on the floor.
4- I count my breaths ensuring that they are always at least 4 counts in and out.By the time this is all done the pose is over! My point is that I am focusing my brain on everything EXCEPT for the fact that I am really tired and about ready to fall over, throw up, pass out, whatever. At the same time I really talk the pose up to myself. Stuff like–wow, this pose feels great, I love the way my spine feels in this twist, my legs look really powerful today.
Anyway–these are things that have worked for me. Good luck and keep us posted re: your progress!
Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: I did it !!! #4957Good luck and enjoy yourself!
in reply to: Hormones and Hot Yoga #4938Things are actually going ok now. My doctor was correct in saying that things could stabilize within the month. I guess that it was just a shock to my system to suddenly stop the birth control pills. Also, I am 46 years old and might be experiencing some declining hormone levels due to perimenopause. I feel like the yoga has helped, but there is really no way to tell. I DO know that it helps me cope and helps my mood,etc.
I am REALLY impressed by your ability to deal with hormone level issues and your hip fracture, etc. You are very dedicated to keep up the yoga in the face of all of that. I actually think about you in class sometimes when I am feeling challenged. Thanks for the inspiration!
in reply to: Yoga Competitions #4892Hi Lee,
I’m glad that you chimed in on this thread. The championship experience sounds like it was a good one. I have two sons who competed in baseball and football from grade school to college. I don’t believe there was ever a time when a competing coach or parent did anything to help them out. How old is your son? Do you think that he will compete again?Namaste,
Cindyin reply to: How necessary is the heat ? #4861I usually ask first timers what they thought of the class after their first one. Nearly all of them say ‘I loved it!’ as they sit there red-faced and dripping. Many of them also say it is the hardest workout that they have ever had. Most of them come back again.
in reply to: I did it !!! #4852Wow!! I can’t even imagine what it would be like to do three classes in one day. Congrats on doing that and I’m glad that you’re feeling better.
in reply to: How necessary is the heat ? #4851I’ll chime in on Gabrielle’s comment re: “palpable change in ones life…” After I had been doing Bikram for a short time, I suddenly stopped drinking soda altogether. This was a bad habit that I had had since college. I had tried to quit before, but just never made the commitment to doing it. Suddenly, I just didn’t want it anymore. It wasn’t even a conscious decision. The same can be said for my food choices. I just automatically eat more healthfully now.
Also, I didn’t think that I would be able to take the heat, but it hasn’t been a problem.
in reply to: Is it quad flexibility or something else? #4850Gabrielle,
I didn’t really tell you the whole story. I have a longtime hamstring injury (it’s been about 2 1/2 years) that I am continuing to try to heal. This has cut back on my hamstring flexibility big time. It hadn’t really occurred to me that my hamstrings could keep me from getting my butt down in half-tortoise or challenge me in fixed firm, but I can see now how that might be true.
Yesterday I asked my instructor to press down on my lower back during half-tortoise so that I could feel the source of the tightness. It is definitely in the glutes. That makes sense since I haven’t been able to really stretch my hamstrings (and correspondingly the glutes) for a long time. I also noticed that, when she pressed down on my back, my body pulled back so far that my chin was only about an inch from my knees. Does this mean that my spine is not straight enough? I do have long legs in proportion to my body. Oh well, maybe some day I’ll work my butt down to my heels, or maybe I won’t.
With regards to Fixed Firm: I can get my butt solidly on the floor if I work at it in the setup. To do so I have to hunch forward a bit and wriggle back and forth to get it to the floor. I also pull down on my ankles a little (not hard and there isn’t any discomfort). Also, I tried spreading my knees pretty wide and that helps. Once I get down, I straighten up and then arch back until my shoulders are on the floor. Once in the pose I have no problem planting my shoulder blades and hips and arching into a bridge. I think that this approach may be a little unorthodox, but is it ok?
All that said, I think that my hamstrings may ultimately be causing the issue. I started Bikram a year ago to attempt to heal them. It is primarily the left hamstring and it is painful at the very top where it connects just below the buttocks. I believe that the injury was caused by overstretching in Vinyasa yoga. Internet research said that this is becoming a common injury in yoga and that the only way to heal it was to stop stretching it. I started Bikram because I felt that I could continue doing yoga, but it was slow enough that I could control the level of hamstring stretching better.
Well, they were ok for awhile, and then not, and then ok again, and then not… Right now I am doing a 60 day challenge. I am going to see if this helps to work through the issue. If I still have a problem at the end of June, I’m planning to contact a physical therapist to try to figure this out.
Sorry for the long post. Thank you for helping me figure this out.
Namaste,
Cindy -
AuthorPosts