The Hot Yoga Doctor – Free Bikram and Hot Yoga Resources › Hot Yoga Doctor Forum › Busting Some Big-A$$ Hot Yoga Myths
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
in reply to: My towel :( #10772
Hey…sorry you felt yelled at. At least your name wasn’t shouted out! This class can indeed be strict. It is a beginner’s class and there is little tolerance for using props or changing the postures, unless instructed to do so. Hopefully your instructor is also caring and helpful.
It sounds like you are bringing an extra towel into class with you. Is that to use as you described or for wiping sweat? I used to bring a hand towel in with me also at the beginning of my practice. Over time, I learned not to use it and then stopped bringing it in at all. The only posture where a prop is used in that class is in Rabbit, because in that posture losing your grip on your heels can cause injury. But you don’t need it for other postures. It might seem like you do, and I understand your frustration in being corrected for something that made sense for you to do. But you don’t actually need the towel. Over time, you will learn to do the posture without the towel, and without the slipping. I admit that I sometimes wipe my hands on my towel just before I grab my knee, but otherwise work on the grip and you will be fine. If the grip slips, just redo it.
The other posture where people tend to “cheat” in my class is Triangle….they position themselves so one foot is on their towel/mat, to keep from slipping. But here too you can learn to do the posture without slipping, as your muscles improve and you figure out how to engage the thigh muscles to keep your position without sliding. It seems nearly impossible in the beginning!
Hang in there. I encourage you to talk with your instructor about any instruction or correction you don’t understand.
Namaste!
-Kristin
in reply to: body image issues #10755Does not sound crazy at all. I think a lot of people struggle with what you describe. This yoga is very challenging physically, but sometimes (ok most of the time) the mental part of it is just as hard, or harder. Learning to be able to turn those thoughts off is key, but also incredibly difficult.
Do your thoughts take form? Meaning, are there actually specific words you say to yourself? Or just an internal emotional reaction? One thing that might help is coming up with a few positive statements that you can say to yourself when you are faced with the negativity. As an example, if you tell yourself your stomach is flabby, find something appealing instead….maybe its the tone of your skin, or the feminine nature of its curve, or whatever. Find something, and replace your negative thought with the positive one. Instead of focusing on a flabby stomach, remind yourself that your practice is strengthening your core….empowering you from the inside out. What is a positive image for you might not be the same as for someone else, but find something and use it to counter act the negativity.
Over time, it will be nice to just notice the “youness” of you, without positive or negative judgment, but for now, it seems like you need a balance to the other side.
I hope that helps. And congrats for what sounds like a really strong practice!
– Kristin
in reply to: I can finally touch, no, HOLD my toes! #10710Congratulations!! For the “not so naturally flexible types” (like me) that is quite an accomplishment. 😆
in reply to: Deepening Backbending #10664Hi Jackie! I think this is a common problem for people, at least those of us who spend most of the day hunched over a computer. Gabrielle has given you some great ideas to try. I wanted to add my two cents from a posture clinic I did in the spring with a well known yogi and King of back bends. We worked on the backbend in half moon and in camel. For half moon he confirmed how easy it is to bend from the lower back and how hard it is to bend the upper back (it naturally bends the other way). So here is what we sweated over for a while:
Stand in preparation for half moon with arms over head as usual. We were told that no matter what, we could not bend from the lower back, period. So he repeated endlessly, press the palms together stretch UP and bring the arms back….press the palms together stretch UP and bring the arms back. This went on for a while, I couldn’t believe how much I was sweating just doing this. But the point was as we were bringing our arms back only, (head too of course), we were focusing all the bend in the thoracic spine, not the lumbar area. And it was critical to press the palms together and stretch the arms and spine up (to elongate it and create space) before bringing the arms back further and further. Finally, he said to include the lower back, and we all went way back (we were faced away from the mirror so that once we were in the backbend, we could see ourselves in the mirror).
We did a regular class after this posture clinic, and for the FIRST TIME EVER, after 2 and a half years of practice, I could see my own matt in the backbend. I came out of the posture with a big grin on my face!
I felt kind of stupid, because the dialogue clearly says to keep the arms back and try to touch the wall behind you, but it wasn’t until this posture clinic that I truly understood the importance of that detail, how critical it is to keep stretching your arms up and back (and eventually toward the floor as you get that far….reach for what you can see) because doing so is lengthening the spine. Otherwise, you just crunch into the lower back, which is easier to do but will never get you that full back bend you are looking for.
anyway, I hope this helps a little, as part of the other interventions you’ve already been given.
-Kristin
in reply to: Kidneys & High blood pressure #10555Good question, and I am not a doctor and don’t profess to know from a medical standpoint. But, my sister has kidney disease (IgA nephropathy) and she practiced Bikram yoga until her kidneys declined to the point that she had to go on dialysis. Her doctor was very concerned about the impact of the heat and the sweating on her kidneys, but my sister found that from doing the practice, she did not have to restrict her potassium or sodium nearly as much (she sweat it all out) and felt pretty good overall. At her studio, students are discouraged from drinking water during class, but given my sister’s condition, the instructor was supportive of her need to drink water, and even made comments during class to make sure she was drinking enough.
At one point, as her kidney functioning continued to decline, the doctors insisted she stop the yoga. She did, taking a break of almost a month until her next blood work. The next test showed the same trend, certainly no improvement, so it seemed that stopping the yoga did not help, and doing the yoga did not hurt, so she went back to class. Once she had to start home dialysis, she obviously had to stop, although now she feels so good she talks about going back to yoga.
She also struggled with the blood pressure issue, but from my perspective, when she was going to yoga AND hydrating properly (throughout the day, not just in class), her BP was under better control. Her doctor was understandably concerned, because he had seen people come into his office in renal failure because of extreme hydration, and he didn’t want the yoga to further damage my sister’s kidneys. By the end of her yoga practice, her doctor seemed to have reconsidered his opinion on the yoga…he wasn’t as against it as before, and even joked that he should give it a try.
I hope this information helps you. My biggest recommendation is to track your condition closely, hydrate well, and listen to your body.
-kristin
in reply to: bikram yoga or hot yoga – weight loss #10464I believe it would certainly help with the anxiety and the toning. As for weight loss, I’m kind of in the same category as you. After practicing Bikram yoga for about two years, I lost about two pounds. Not a ton, and like you, I wasn’t really interested in losing weight. My opinion, based on my own experience, is that diet has a much bigger impact on weight loss than exercise alone. I know some folks out there will disagree with me, but there is literature to support it too. Anyway, my point is that I believe if you watch your diet, ensure you are getting enough calories, you should be fine. You may “lose” a couple pounds after class, from sweating, but that is temporary until you can rehydrate.
Good luck!
in reply to: The heat is too much for my knee health #10437Ok, I’ll jump in. At my studio, it is typically 105 degrees and 40% humidity. I can have some pretty good classes in those conditions but it is challenging. Once in a while, the conditions are more extreme….heat is higher or humidity is higher, or both. I end up having to sit out postures and I don’t feel like I’m really getting the benefits from the class that I want. In fact, I’ve experienced what seems like an inflammatory reaction in those classes (some joint pain). In one class, I checked it at the end and it was 108 and 60% humidity. Put that info into an internet site to find a heat index of 162! Ok, no wonder I felt so bad!
Sometimes this has to do with the outside conditions (it was very humid outside that day, for example), and you can’t just lower the temperature, because that increases the relative humidity. I do mention it to the instructors, some are better at controlling the conditions than others.
Lets just say that if all my classes were like that, I’d stop going. I just don’t see the point. I already feel at my threshold, so pushing the conditions to that level is just too much for me, though some folks can do it without obvious problem.
On the other hand, I’ve been in a few classes where it was “cooler” (like 101) and the humidity was very low (problem with equipment). I didn’t like that class as much either, and it seemed like my throat was raw from breathing less humid air.
Just my experience/opinion. I know I’ll never want to go to a studio where it is a competition to see how hot/humid they can make it.
Well of course you try, but focus more on good form now, not depth so much. That will come with time. No one starts out looking like those folks!
I would definitely recommend finding some source where you can learn more about the form and right way to do each posture. This site is a good start, but you will need to keep researching if you aren’t taking a class somewhere and can get instruction. You might even check You Tube by putting in “Bikram” and the pose name, there are some videos of classes doing particular postures. That way you can see the broad variety of people’s abilities and see them in action.
It sounds like you did just Half Moon (the two side bends with backbend). In the actual class, the next pose (hands to feet) is incorporated into Half Moon as well, so bend to the right, to the left, back bend, then hands to feet. That would technically be two poses (in this series).
Half moon is more challenging than it looks, it is an endurance pose. You could back off the intensity a little (don’t go too deep) at first until you get used to it. The most important thing is making sure you have proper form, breathe, and stick with it. Are you working with a book or video? Gabrielle’s book (now in paperback) would help you with that. I’m concerned that you are in so much pain from that pose alone, so do make sure you research as best you can on how to do each pose properly.
Good luck!
The side bend that comes right after the breathing exercise is Half Moon. it includes the bend to both sides, as well as the back bend.
At the end of class is the final breathing exercise, blowing in firm pose.
Of course this is assuming you are doing the typical Bikram class.
If you look at the main forum page, there is a list of all of these, in order. You can see that all the postures have “asana” in the name, and there are breathing exercises at the beginning and end.
Hope that helps!
Hi Rob, and welcome!
Hot yoga can be a wonderful antidote to anxiety, for several reasons. As you have already experienced, you will be challenging yourself to stick with it, even if you feel anxious, and learning that you CAN do it, even if you may want to dart out of the room. This challenges the avoidance aspect of anxiety. There are also aspects of the class that are quite similar to techniques psychologists use to treat anxiety….in particular, the spine strengthening series that combines brief but intense muscle contraction followed by complete relaxation. Exercise in general is helpful for anxiety, its hard to feel anxious when you are physically exhausted. And finally, and importantly, the class is designed to teach you to turn off your brain. That’s a powerful tool, particularly if you can start to do that outside of class.
I recommend yoga in general (but hot yoga in particular) to people with anxiety for these reasons. I do hope you will continue to post and let us know how the anxiety is going, both in and out of the yoga room. You will likely encounter some classes where the anxiety seems to return….don’t get frustrated, just work on calming that “monkey mind”, your relaxation techniques (the breathing, keeping the eyes still), and I predict you will make great strides.
Namaste,
-Kristin
in reply to: Worse than I thought : ( #10211Yes, as a hair dresser I would guess that you are prone to a lot of muscle tension from standing and working with your arms/hands all day.
Of course it will be important to understand how you injured you neck (if you don’t already know) so you can avoid that in the future. For me, it was just being stupid in coming out of a posture (fixed firm) and my entire neck froze up. Gabrielle helped me problem solve the source of it and I haven’t had a problem since. But it took a month or more before I was back to normal postures.
I think living with chronic illness/injury can color your self-perception. I’m glad part of your perception is “strength”, and applaud your stamina to keep doing what is good for your physical and mental health.
in reply to: Worse than I thought : ( #10209I’m so sorry, you sound pretty dejected with this injury!
I’ve had a few injuries throughout my yoga practice, and I have to say that getting back into the room and modifying the postures as necessary was what ended up healing me. With a neck injury, I could barely have my arm over my head, which impacted a whole LOT of postures. But I knew with gentle effort, heat, and time, it would improve. And of course it did. I just set up on the back row where my modifications wouldn’t be as distracting to others, and of course talked with my instructor about the injury and what postures I would need to change.
I also tried therapeutic massage and various creams, but I’m not sure how much of those helped. The yoga certainly did.
Try not to get too discouraged. You obviously have put a lot of work into becoming as strong as you are. That should help you in the recovery, assuming you can let your mind accept that sometimes in life, we do get injured, and we can learn from it and move on.
Namaste.
-Kristin
in reply to: Perspectives from a Student #10208I completely agree about teachers who give feedback versus those who don’t! If I get any feedback (compliment or correction) I’m amazed at how I’m suddenly working even harder, though I would have thought that impossible. Of course correcting misalignments is critical, and not all instructors do that. For the teachers who simply recite the dialogue, I feel like they are “phoning it in” and I end up doing the same.
Of course I also like instructors who bring a degree of energy and enthusiasm to the class. Even though it may be the same words I’ve heard countless times, they say them as if its the first time they’ve spoken them. That keeps me in the class, mentally.
in reply to: age and Bikram #10091Oh I so agree with you about not knowing how we look to others! I am definitely not the youngest chicken in class, not the oldest either. I feel like I struggle so much, and yet after one class a student paid me a compliment, “You have such a strong practice!”. Really?? So you just never know, and in the end it doesn’t matter. I’m so glad you enjoy the class, that’s really all that matters.
Namaste!
-Kristin
in reply to: age and Bikram #10086Good for you! Never too late IMO, and at any age you have to listen to your body to know where your limits are. This is a link from the studio I go to, about one of the Students of the Month. She is an inspiration to me. Read her story, and you will see why.
http://bikramyogasavannah.com/arlene-meyer/
Don’t compare yourself to other students. It is your practice, and if you love it, keep going!
-Kristin
in reply to: Can yoga cause/cure a hernia? #10073I am sure Gabriella will have more insight from a technical standpoint than I. The mix of different styles of yoga does complicate it (for me anyway).
The only reason I mentioned floor bow was from my own experience. The message I got was to maintain the core stability in that posture, rather than pushing against the floor with the abdomen, if that makes sense. I will definitely be interested to hear input from others on this topic.
in reply to: Can yoga cause/cure a hernia? #10071Are you feeling discomfort in that area in any particular posture? I had an uncomfortable feeling in the abdomen during floor bow, and wondered to myself if it was possible to cause a hernia from that. I talked to my teachers. One told me that it is possible to get greater height with the legs in that position by pushing against the floor with the abdomen, but that is not what you should do…instead the focus should be in the back muscles. Another instructor mentioned that the 80/20 breathing is important in part because it maintains tension in the core muscles….if you exhale completely in that posture, you may feel a relaxing of the abdominal wall. In fact, I had noticed that, and also noticed losing strength and “lift” if I exhaled too much.
After receiving this feedback, I was mindful about those issues particularly during floor bow, and have not re-experienced that odd sensation.
I will be curious to hear what others have to say on this topic. As for the ability to cure a hernia, I’m afraid I have no input there. Good luck and good healing!
– kristin
in reply to: do i need to do more than just bikram? #10059I guess that depends on your personal goals. For me, one of the things I love about this yoga is that it improves muscle tone, strength, flexibility, mental focus, and cardio. I don’t feel like I need anything else, which is good, because I’m a bit lazy. :red:
My own goals primarily involve being healthy overall and staying toned. Bikram yoga has accomplished that for me.
– kristin
in reply to: Savasana on my stomach anxiety #10047I really haven’t found any particular change in position on the floor to make much difference, other than ensuring the chin is not tucked so that my airway is completely unobstructed. My main focus is to relax, completely. And also to make sure I am breathing properly BEFORE this series, so I don’t go into it with a deficit.
If its a particularly hot class, I find it even harder to breathe, because I’m also not cooling off properly. Staying calm and relaxed becomes even more important.
Always open to anyone’s tips…….
-Kristin
in reply to: Yoga Socks & Gloves #10009I’m trying to figure out when your hands would slip in a Bikram class? Can you say what pose that is? Also, do you have a towel on top of your mat?
-Kristin
in reply to: Savasana on my stomach anxiety #9887I sometimes have that experience too. I believe there is a physical reason for part of it….one, you are lying on your chest so breathing isn’t as effortless as when you are on your back. Two, about half your airspace is cut out (being taken up by the floor). So if I haven’t been keeping up with my breathing, then it seems hard to regain my breath in this posture. If I have the slightest bit of congestion, then its really a challenge and I start feeling hotter and a bit anxious.
You seem to be doing some good things from a focus standpoint. The only other thing I would suggest is to really concentrate on breathing well before this part of class (such as the savasana right before it, nice big oxygenating breaths), and of course make sure you are breathing well during the postures themselves.
Gabrielle: your tip for scooting the scapulae together while on the back really does make a difference in breathing….but what about on the stomach?
– Kristin
in reply to: Bikram and hangovers? #9851Yes, hydrate very well, and the class itself seems to help clear out all those toxins! (not that I am speaking from experience or anything….:red:)
– Kristin
in reply to: Totally out of control #9806Hi Cheermom,
you sound hard on yourself! I’ve been doing this hot yoga now for almost two years, and I still have to work on my breath. And my balance. Even though I thought I was focusing on breath in the beginning, it became apparent to me that I wasn’t.
I know you like the back row, but I have found that if I am a bit closer to the mirror I am less distracted by other things, I breathe a bit better, and I balance a bit better. I’m near sighted so if I’m on the back row I feel like I am WAY far away, making focusing on myself harder in general. Just a thought for you to consider.
Just keep in mind that everyone in that class struggles with things all the time. No need for you to be embarrassed. I hope you stick with it and find your focus.
Namaste!
-Kristin
-
AuthorPosts